Burial Insurance vs. Prepaid Funeral Plans
Burial insurance pays cash to a person you choose, who can use any funeral home for anything. A prepaid funeral plan is a contract with one funeral home for certain goods and services, paid in advance. Insurance is more flexible. A prepaid plan can lock in specific arrangements, and an irrevocable one can be useful when Medicaid is involved.
Neither is right for everyone. Here is how they compare, and the questions to ask before you sign either one.
The main differences
| Burial insurance | Prepaid funeral plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Who gets the money | The beneficiary you name | The funeral home |
| What it can pay for | Anything: funeral, cremation, cemetery, bills | The goods and services in the contract |
| If you move | Goes with you; any funeral home can be used | Depends on the contract and state law; transfers may cost extra |
| How you pay | Monthly premiums, often for life | Lump sum or installments |
| Health questions | Usually, unless guaranteed issue | Depends on the plan; ask the seller |
What happens if you move or the funeral home closes?
This is where the two differ most. Insurance pays a person, so it does not matter where you live or which funeral home is open. With a prepaid plan, it depends on how the money was protected and what the contract says.
The Federal Trade Commission suggests asking these questions before you prepay:
- What exactly am I paying for: merchandise only, or services too?
- What happens to the money I pay? States have different rules for how prepaid funds must be held.
- What happens to any interest the money earns?
- Am I protected if the funeral home goes out of business?
- Can I cancel and get a full refund if I change my mind?
- What happens if I move, or die while away from home?
The FTC also notes that some states require part of a prepayment to go into a state-regulated trust, or into a life insurance policy with the funeral home as the beneficiary. So some prepaid plans are funded by insurance behind the scenes. Arkansas, for example, regulates prepaid funeral contracts through its Insurance Department; see our Arkansas guide.
Prepaid funerals, burial insurance, and Medicaid
Medicaid is where the choice can matter most. For people who may need nursing home care, Medicaid limits how much money and property a person can have. Many state programs exclude some money set aside for burial, but the rules and dollar amounts differ by state.
A few points apply broadly:
- Irrevocable is the key word. An irrevocable prepaid funeral contract cannot be cancelled for a refund. Because the person cannot get the money back, it is often not counted the way cash is. Under the federal SSI resource rule, for example, money in an irrevocable burial contract is treated separately from countable savings, and it reduces the separate $1,500 burial-fund exclusion. Your state's Medicaid program sets its own rules.
- A revocable plan may count. If the contract can be cancelled for a refund, the refund value may be treated like savings.
- Life insurance cash value may count. Some states count the cash value of whole life policies over a certain face amount. Our state guides explain the limits for Alabama, Arkansas, Iowa, Louisiana, Maryland, Missouri, Ohio, and Tennessee.
- Estate recovery is a separate issue. After death, states must try to recover certain Medicaid costs from the estates of people who were 55 or older. Money left in a funeral contract or paid to "the estate" can be part of that. A life insurance payout to a named, living beneficiary is usually paid directly to that person.
Before you buy, cancel, or change anything while on Medicaid or applying, talk with your state Medicaid office or an elder-law attorney. Do not drop a policy or a contract on your own, because it could create a problem with eligibility.
If a parent already has an old prepaid plan
Families often find a plan a parent bought years ago. Before anyone pays again:
- Find the contract and the name of the funeral home, or the company that now owns it.
- Ask what it covers today. Some older plans guaranteed prices; others only credit the amount paid.
- Ask for a current General Price List so you can see what is not covered. Under the FTC Funeral Rule, the funeral home must give you one when you ask in person.
- If the parent is on Medicaid, ask the caseworker how the contract was counted before you change it.
Can you use both?
Yes. Some families prepay a basic service with the funeral home and keep a small insurance policy for the cemetery, headstone, final bills, and travel. Others keep insurance only, so the family can choose later. Write down your wishes and tell your family where the papers are. The FTC warns that if family members do not know about prepaid plans, they could end up paying for the arrangements again.
Common questions
Is a prepaid funeral better than burial insurance?
It depends on your goal. A prepaid plan can lock in a specific funeral home's services. Insurance pays cash to a person and works with any funeral home, even if you move.
What happens to a prepaid funeral plan if I move to another state?
It depends on the contract and state law. Some plans can be transferred, sometimes for a fee. Ask before you sign.
Does a prepaid funeral count against Medicaid?
An irrevocable contract is often not counted like savings, but a revocable one may be. Each state sets its own rules, so check with your state Medicaid office.
Can I cancel a prepaid funeral plan?
A revocable plan can usually be cancelled, though refunds vary. An irrevocable plan generally cannot be cancelled for a refund.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission, Paying Final Respects: Your Rights When Buying Funeral Goods and Services (prepaying section), via GovInfo https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GOVPUB-FT-PURL-gpo52591/pdf/GOVPUB-FT-PURL-gpo52591.pdf
- Federal Trade Commission Funeral Rule, 16 CFR Part 453 (price lists, phone price disclosure, casket and embalming rules) https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-D/part-453
- 20 CFR 416.1231, Burial spaces and certain funds set aside for burial expenses (federal SSI resource rule) https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-20/chapter-III/part-416/subpart-L/section-416.1231
- Medicaid.gov, Estate Recovery https://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid/eligibility-policy/estate-recovery
RateShop Life is an independent licensed insurance agency. Coverage, rates and availability vary by state, age and health. This page is general information, not legal, tax, or Medicaid advice.